Who Were You, Pierre Plantard...
21 November 2026
On 14 September 2019 someone wrote the following about Pierre Plantard:
“In short, he's being portrayed as a pathological liar, a forger, or a swindler. As Geneviève Béduneau so aptly puts it, Pierre Plantard deserves neither this trial for unworthiness or a hagiography.”
Nor does any other confidence trickster or swindler! Both Pierre Plantard and Philippe de Chérisey must have LAUGHED their heads off at all the dim believers who took all their nonsensical stories that could be discredited with the simplest of ease! But Plantard pushed his envelope of deception much too far and got himself into trouble for making false claims about Roger-Patrice Pelat and received a severe legal warning from the French authorities, after which he forsook his nonsensical activities. Nothing more from him was ever heard of again following this episode.
But this episode is not really needed to put Plantard into his place. You only need to consult his entire material from the 1920s to 1990 to realise he belonged to the world of make-believe. Neither Marshal Philippe Pétain nor General Charles de Gaulle were interested in these type of Fringe Beliefs that people like Plantard belonged to.
The very same thing can be said about the current generation of believers that have forsaken the world of reality in order to wallow in pleasant escapism. Like for example claiming the fantastic myths about “Claudia Procula” who ultimately originates from the Gospel of Matthew – and the Gospels only date from 150 CE (a fact that we are all radicalised to ignore, you will never get a television discussion about it, that’s for sure). It has to be remembered that Christian scholars prefer to criticise and humiliate present-day atheists and agnostics rather than to admit and to acknowledge the existence of Christians who denied the physical substance of Jesus Christ during the early centuries.
In essence, what we see time and time again – is the way that the Believers latch on to their favourite conspiracy theories and transform them onto Rennes-le-Château – that’s what we have witnessed for the past 70 years since the mid-1950s. Everyone has got their own wacky beliefs that get super-glued onto Rennes-le-Château and the Priory of Sion. For decades it was very fashionable for Believers to turn the Priory of Sion into a Left-Wing Society (that Philippe Marlin laughed at) – and this craze eventually died out. But it’s all reappearing again in a book that is promoted on the Gazette de Rennes-le-Chateau website. People from a Jewish background certainly need to have a belief in the Priory of Sion so long as it was not pro-Hitler – but rather the Left-Wing version of Stalin – and Gérard de Sède was deeply involved in Far-Left, specifically Trotskyist, Politics. Although he was born into an aristocratic French family (he was the Baron de Liéoux), his early life and intellectual background were firmly rooted in Revolutionary Socialism. This is the probable cause why Gérard de Sède took all the Royalties of his book “L’Or de Rennes” and did not split it with Plantard and de Chérisey – because at heart Gérard de Sède wasn’t a Monarchist – and this was why Pierre Plantard amd Philippe de Chérisey admitted that they faked the parchments, so they could scupper the popularity of Gérard de Sède’s book.
There are big counter-arguments against the existence of the recently ridiculous “Jewish Priory of Sion” book – Abbé Boullan’s work centered on mysticism, heterodox Christian theology, and esotericism rather than political ideology or party politics. Although Boullan was briefly associated with Chanoine Roca, a socialist-leaning occultist priest, Boullan's own writings were entirely focused on spiritual warfare, exorcism, and Millennialist Prophecy rather than Secular Political Reform.
As for Eugène Vintras – he wasn’t Left-Wing either; his movement was deeply rooted in the Right-Wing, Legitimist Royalism. While his unconventional mysticism led both the Catholic Church and the French State to view him as a subversive radical, his actual political alignment belonged to the Counter-Revolutionary Monarchist camp of 19th-century France. Vintras rose to prominence in 1839 through a secret monarchist society known as the Saviours of Louis XVII. In the political spectrum of post-revolutionary France, Legitimists – who sought to restore the senior Bourbon line to the throne – represented the traditional, Conservative Right Wing, standing in direct opposition to Left-Wing Republicans and Socialists. Vintras actively used his prophecies to champion Royalist Claimants to the French Throne, most notably Karl Wilhelm Naundorff, a prominent Pretender who claimed to be the surviving Louis XVII. Pope Gregory XVI condemned Vintras in 1843 and had him imprisoned – but his clashes with the establishment stemmed from religious heresy (the Œuvre de la Miséricorde) and loyalty to a rival Royalist Faction, rather than any Left-Wing or Egalitarian Ideology.
Of course, the mind of the Believer in Conspiracy Theories can change into any shape it likes, because it does not observe logical common sense and instead acts as a Shape Shifting Catalyst.
|